Dinnerly and Home Chef are both meal kits that arrive weekly, include fresh ingredients and recipe instructions, and let you skip or cancel without fees. After testing both, I found the gap between them is larger than the price difference suggests. Dinnerly is genuinely the bare-minimum version of a meal kit: fewest ingredients, no printed cards, lowest price. Home Chef is a proper mid-range service with protein swaps, oven-ready options, and broader weekly selection. Whether that gap is worth $80–$120/month to your household is the question worth answering.
Last updated: May 2026. Prices and plan details verified against each service’s current website.
Quick verdict: Dinnerly wins on price and is a solid choice for households that cook comfortably from a phone and want the lowest weekly cost. Home Chef wins on flexibility: protein swaps, oven-ready options, printed recipe cards, and a broader weekly menu. If any of those features matter to your household, Home Chef is worth the premium.
- Dinnerly has no printed recipe cards. Instructions are digital-only via app or website. If you prefer a card on the counter, this is a weekly friction point.
- Home Chef protein swap upcharges are typically $2–$4 per meal. Factor these into your actual weekly cost when comparing sticker prices.
- Dinnerly uses only 5–6 ingredients per meal, which means simpler flavors and less prep. Home Chef recipes use more ingredients and produce more complex results.
- Home Chef is available in Kroger-family grocery stores if you want to try a meal before subscribing online.
Ratings Scorecard
| Category | Dinnerly | Home Chef |
|---|---|---|
| Price per meal | 9/10 | 6/10 |
| Shipping cost | 9/10 | 8/10 |
| Recipe cards | 3/10 | 9/10 |
| Recipe variety | 6/10 | 8/10 |
| Protein customization | 2/10 | 9/10 |
| Oven-ready option | 0/10 | 8/10 |
| Ingredients per meal | 5/10 | 8/10 |
| Overall value | 8/10 | 7/10 |
Dinnerly vs Home Chef at a Glance
| Category | Dinnerly | Home Chef |
|---|---|---|
| Price per meal | $4.99–$8.99 | $9.95–$13.95 |
| Shipping | $8.99 | $9.99 |
| Recipes per week | 40+ | 30+ |
| Ingredients per meal | 5–6 | 8–10 |
| Recipe cards | Digital only | Printed (included) |
| Protein swaps | No | Yes (on many meals) |
| Oven-ready option | No | Yes |
| Best for | Lowest weekly cost | Flexibility and customization |
Pricing: What You Actually Pay
Dinnerly wins on both per-meal price and shipping. For a 2-person household on a 3-meal plan:
| 2 people, 3 meals/week | Dinnerly | Home Chef |
|---|---|---|
| Per meal | ~$5.99 | ~$10.99 |
| Weekly food cost | ~$36 | ~$66 |
| Shipping | $8.99 | $9.99 |
| Weekly total | ~$45 | ~$76 |
| Monthly difference | Dinnerly saves ~$124/month | |
Dinnerly Deep Dive
Dinnerly is built to be the cheapest meal kit that still functions as a proper service. It achieves this through digital-only recipe cards (no printing cost), 5–6 ingredients per meal (less purchasing and prep complexity), lower shipping, and lean recipe development. Despite being the most stripped-down option, Dinnerly actually offers 40+ recipes per week, one of the larger selections in the budget-kit segment.
The digital-only recipe system is the main trade-off. If you cook comfortably from your phone or tablet, this is a non-issue. If you prefer a card on the counter, want to hand off a card to a family member, or cook in a kitchen where a phone is inconvenient, you will notice the absence every single week.
Try Dinnerly: Get Dinnerly for as low as $2.17 per meal on your first box. Offer varies.
Home Chef Deep Dive
Home Chef sits comfortably in the mid-range: more expensive than Dinnerly but meaningfully more flexible. Protein swaps let you customize the protein on many weekly meals, a feature Dinnerly cannot match. Oven-ready options let you do zero active cooking on nights when that matters. Printed recipe cards are included. The weekly menu covers 30+ options with more complex recipes than Dinnerly’s stripped-down format allows.
The ingredient count is higher too. Home Chef recipes typically use 8–10 ingredients versus Dinnerly’s 5–6. More ingredients means more prep and more complexity, but also more flavor depth and more interesting food. The meals taste noticeably more developed than Dinnerly’s intentionally simplified approach.
Try Home Chef: Get $90 off your first four Home Chef boxes. Offer varies.
The Final Call
Dinnerly wins if budget is the top priority and you are comfortable with digital-only recipe cards. Home Chef wins if any of these matter to you: protein customization, a hands-off oven night option, printed recipe cards, or more complex and flavorful cooking results.
For a full picture of how these compare to the mainstream market, see HelloFresh vs Dinnerly and HelloFresh vs Home Chef. If Dinnerly’s price is the main draw, also compare Dinnerly vs Factor to see how it stacks up against a no-cook service.
Packaging and Delivery Experience
Dinnerly: Dinnerly keeps packaging minimal by design — this is part of how the service delivers at $4.99/serving. The insulated liner is thinner than premium brands, and recipes arrive with digital-only cards (no printed recipe cards included in the box). Ingredients are labeled and grouped per recipe. Portion bags are minimal. The approach is intentionally stripped-down, which reduces waste but also reduces the premium unboxing feel.
Home Chef: Home Chef ships in a standard corrugated box with a thick insulated liner and individual zip-lock bags labeled by recipe. Proteins arrive vacuum-sealed in the bottom of the liner on top of gel ice. The packaging is clean and functional rather than premium. Home Chef also offers pickup at participating Kroger stores, which eliminates delivery packaging entirely — a real sustainability win for shoppers near a Kroger.
Packaging: roughly even. Dinnerly: Minimal by design — thinner liner, no printed recipe cards. Keeps costs down but not for those who value premium packaging. Home Chef: Practical and reliable. Not premium-feeling, but the Kroger pickup option is genuinely useful for reducing delivery waste.
App and Digital Experience
Dinnerly: Dinnerly's app (iOS 4.5 / Android 3.8) is functional for meal selection and delivery management. Since Dinnerly relies on digital recipe cards (accessed via app or browser), the recipe-browsing experience is important — and it's adequate but not exceptional. The Android version has received more mixed reviews. Weekly meal selection is straightforward; the interface is simple and loads quickly.
Home Chef: The Home Chef app (iOS 4.8 / Android 4.3) integrates with Kroger accounts for seamless pickup and delivery management. The meal customization features — protein swaps, calorie-smart options, oven-ready upgrades — are easy to access in-app. Recipe cards display well on mobile. It's one of the more capable apps in the meal kit space.
App edge: Home Chef. Solid — Kroger integration is a genuine differentiator. Customization is well-executed. One of the better meal kit apps.
Customer Service and Account Management
Dinnerly: Dinnerly offers email and chat support during business hours. Response times are decent but slower than HelloFresh-owned brands. The self-service portal handles skips and plan changes, though the cancel flow is more involved than budget competitors like EveryPlate. Refund credits are issued for quality issues within 2–3 business days.
Home Chef: Home Chef's support combines web chat, email, and Kroger in-store assistance for pickup orders. Response times via chat are generally quick (under 10 minutes during business hours). The online account portal lets you skip, pause, change plans, and cancel without friction. Refund credits for delivery issues post to your account within 24 hours.
Customer service: comparable. Dinnerly: Adequate but not standout. Slower than HelloFresh-family brands; the cancel flow adds friction. Email-first support. Home Chef: Good — multi-channel support, clean self-service portal. Kroger integration adds a physical support touchpoint most competitors lack.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Dinnerly or Home Chef cheaper?
Dinnerly is cheaper. Dinnerly is $4.99–$8.99/meal with $8.99 shipping. Home Chef is $9.95–$13.95/meal with $9.99 shipping. For a 2-person, 3-meal plan, Dinnerly saves roughly $124/month.
Does Home Chef have printed recipe cards?
Yes. Home Chef includes printed recipe cards. Dinnerly is digital-only for recipe instructions, accessed via app or website. If printed cards matter to your cooking experience, Home Chef is the clear choice.
Can you swap proteins on Dinnerly?
No. Dinnerly does not offer protein swaps. Home Chef allows protein customization on many weekly meals. This is one of Home Chef’s most useful differentiators.
Does Home Chef offer oven-ready meals?
Yes. Home Chef has oven-ready options requiring under 5 minutes of setup. Dinnerly does not have oven-ready options. Every Dinnerly meal requires active stovetop or oven cooking.
Which is better for a large family, Dinnerly or Home Chef?
Dinnerly is better on price for larger households. Home Chef is better if protein customization matters for different family members. Both offer 4-serving options. For a family of four, Dinnerly saves roughly $200–$250/month compared to Home Chef.
Find your meal kit in 2 minutes
Answer 5 quick questions. We'll match you to the top 3 from 24 services we track.
Compare across all our rankings
- Best Meal Delivery Services of 2026: our master ranking of the top 10 services in the United States.
- Best High Protein Meal Delivery: ranked for athletes, weight management, and GLP 1 friendly meals.
- Best Diabetic Meal Delivery: ranked for Type 2 diabetes, pre diabetes, and insulin support.
- Best GLP 1 Meal Delivery: ranked for Ozempic, Wegovy, Mounjaro, and Zepbound users.
