Marley Spoon vs Purple Carrot (2026): Gourmet Kits vs Vegan Kits

Updated June 2026

Marley Spoon vs Purple Carrot: The Short Version

Marley Spoon and Purple Carrot are among the most comparable meal kits on the market: similar per-serving pricing, similar cook times, both skewed toward premium quality and culinary craft. The critical difference is one you either care about deeply or not at all: Purple Carrot is 100% plant-based and Marley Spoon is not. If your household eats vegan, Purple Carrot is the clear choice. If your household eats meat or simply wants more weekly variety, Marley Spoon offers 20-25 recipes per week vs Purple Carrot's 8-10. The scores are close (7.7/10 vs 7.7/10), with Marley Spoon ahead primarily because of its wider menu selection.

Recipe Selection

Marley Spoon offers 20-25 recipes per week spanning omnivore, vegetarian, and family-friendly options. Martha Stewart's culinary brand drives a focus on technique and quality ingredients across a broad range of cuisines and complexity levels. The variety means most households find multiple recipes they want each week, which is a key factor in subscriber satisfaction and retention over time.

Purple Carrot offers 8-10 recipes per week, all of them vegan by design. The smaller weekly selection is a trade-off for the specialized plant-based focus. Purple Carrot's recipes tend toward creative global cuisines with whole-food plant-based ingredients, and the results are often surprising in how satisfying fully plant-based cooking can be. But the narrower weekly selection can lead to menu fatigue for long-term subscribers.

Price Comparison

These services are almost exactly the same price. Marley Spoon and Purple Carrot both run $9-$12 per serving depending on plan size, with $9.99 shipping on both. For a couple ordering four meals per week, the total weekly cost is nearly identical. If you're choosing between these two services, price is not the deciding factor, diet commitment is.

Bottom Line

Marley Spoon (8.2/10) wins for non-vegan households who want gourmet Martha Stewart recipes with broad weekly variety. Purple Carrot (7.7/10) wins for vegan households who want a fully committed plant-based meal kit at the same price. At identical pricing, diet preference is the decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Marley Spoon or Purple Carrot better?

Marley Spoon scores slightly higher (8.2/10 vs 7.7/10) primarily due to its wider weekly menu (20-25 recipes vs 8-10). Both services are similarly priced at $9-$12/serving with $9.99 shipping. Purple Carrot wins for fully vegan households, 100% plant-based with no filtering needed. Choose based entirely on diet: vegan households should choose Purple Carrot; everyone else should choose Marley Spoon for the variety.

Is Purple Carrot fully vegan and Marley Spoon is not?

Yes. Every Purple Carrot recipe is 100% plant-based with no animal products. Marley Spoon is primarily an omnivore service with vegetarian options that include dairy and eggs. Fully vegan households should choose Purple Carrot; Marley Spoon's vegetarian options don't serve strict vegan diets.

Does Marley Spoon have more recipes than Purple Carrot?

Yes, significantly more. Marley Spoon offers 20-25 recipes per week across omnivore, vegetarian, and family menus. Purple Carrot offers 8-10 plant-based recipes per week. The larger Marley Spoon menu reduces the likelihood of menu fatigue, which is a real issue for long-term Purple Carrot subscribers who eat from the same smaller rotation each week.

Cancel Guide Links

• How to Cancel Marley Spoon
• How to Cancel Purple Carrot

Browse Meals from Each Service

• Browse All Meals on MealFan

Looking for Alternatives?

• Marley Spoon Alternatives
• Purple Carrot Alternatives

Menu Variety: Premium Recipe Kits vs. Specialty Vegan Cooking

Marley Spoon and Purple Carrot are both premium meal kit services, but they approach the market with meaningfully different culinary missions. Marley Spoon is a full-spectrum meal kit with a menu built in partnership with Martha Stewart. The weekly rotation spans 30 to 40 recipes covering American classics, Italian, Mexican, Asian-inspired dishes, and more, with options for two-person and four-person households. The menu includes meat, seafood, and vegetarian options, and the culinary philosophy emphasizes elevated home cooking, dishes that feel restaurant-quality but are achievable for a confident home cook in 30 to 45 minutes. The Martha Stewart influence is most visible in the attention to technique, plating guidance, and use of seasonal ingredients.

Purple Carrot is entirely plant-based. Every recipe on every weekly menu is 100 percent vegan, with no meat, dairy, or eggs whatsoever. The weekly rotation includes 20 or more recipes with a strong emphasis on globally-inspired, inventive plant-based cooking, Korean tofu bowls, roasted cauliflower with harissa, black bean mole, miso-glazed eggplant, cashew cream pasta. Purple Carrot is not a vegetarian-friendly menu within a larger omnivore service; it is a service built from the ground up for plant-based cooks who want serious, creative recipes rather than basic substitutions. The brand is owned by HelloFresh, which provides supply chain stability and delivery reliability.

Pricing Breakdown: Similar Premium Tiers with Different Audiences

Marley Spoon starts at 8.99 per serving on two-person plans. A two-person plan with three recipes per week runs approximately 55 to 60 dollars before a 10.99 shipping fee. The four-person plan brings the per-serving cost down somewhat and is more economical for larger households. Marley Spoon runs regular new-subscriber promotions with discounts of 50 to 60 percent on the first several boxes, making the initial trial accessible. At the ongoing price, Marley Spoon is positioned similarly to HelloFresh but with a higher per-recipe quality due to the Martha Stewart recipe development partnership.

Purple Carrot starts at 11.99 per serving, which is approximately 33 percent more expensive than Marley Spoon on a per-serving basis. A two-person plan with three recipes per week runs approximately 72 to 78 dollars before a 9.99 shipping fee. The higher cost reflects the premium ingredients involved in sourcing quality plant-based proteins and specialty produce, items like lacinato kale, Japanese sweet potatoes, tahini, za'atar, and black garlic that appear routinely in the weekly menu. Purple Carrot also offers a meal prep plan with larger, batch-friendly portions at a slightly lower per-serving rate for subscribers who prefer to cook in bulk once or twice a week.

Cooking and Delivery Experience

Marley Spoon delivers fresh, refrigerated ingredients in a well-insulated cooler box with gel packs and an inner liner that maintains cold chain through overnight transit. The recipe cards are polished and well-photographed, with step-by-step instructions that are clear even for less experienced cooks. Ingredients arrive partially prepped in many cases, spice blends are pre-measured, proteins are trimmed, and in some recipes sauces are partially combined. Active cooking time runs 30 to 45 minutes for most recipes. Ingredient quality is consistently high, particularly for seasonal produce and proteins, and Marley Spoon's sourcing tends toward responsible farming practices.

Purple Carrot delivers equally well-insulated packages with notably high-quality specialty produce at the center of each recipe. The ingredient selection routinely includes items that are genuinely difficult to source at a standard supermarket, and the pre-measured quantities ensure you use specialty ingredients like miso paste or tahini in the exact amounts needed without waste. Recipe prep time is typically 35 to 45 minutes and sometimes longer for more complex dishes. The recipe cards are clearly written and include plating guidance that helps achieve restaurant-quality presentation. For plant-based cooking specifically, the depth of technique instruction in Purple Carrot recipe cards is superior to what general meal kits provide on their vegetarian variants.

Who Should Choose Marley Spoon

Marley Spoon is the stronger choice for households that eat meat and fish alongside vegetarian meals and want a premium, Martha Stewart-quality cooking experience. If you enjoy cooking and appreciate well-developed, elevated recipes with clear technique instruction, Marley Spoon's weekly menu delivers consistent quality across a broad range of cuisines. The per-serving cost is also lower than Purple Carrot, which matters for households feeding two to four people every week. Marley Spoon is particularly well-suited for people who already cook regularly and want better ingredients and more interesting recipes than a budget meal kit provides, without fully committing to the premium tier of Green Chef.

Who Should Choose Purple Carrot

Purple Carrot is the clear choice for vegans and people actively reducing animal products from their diet who want a premium, skill-building cooking experience. The menu quality is the best plant-based cooking instruction available through a weekly meal kit service, and the ingredient sourcing is designed specifically around plant-forward cuisine rather than as an add-on to a meat-focused menu. If you are already vegan and the Marley Spoon menu's vegetarian options feel limited or uninspired by comparison, Purple Carrot will feel like a revelation in terms of weekly variety and culinary creativity. The higher per-serving cost is justified by both ingredient quality and the distinctiveness of the weekly recipe lineup.

Dietary Suitability: Which Service Fits Your Eating Style

Marley Spoon serves omnivores with a broad, mixed menu covering meat, seafood, and vegetarian recipes. The weekly rotation of 30 to 40 recipes includes a meaningful number of vegetarian options, and the Martha Stewart recipe development philosophy emphasizes seasonal, high-quality ingredients across all dietary categories rather than treating vegetarian recipes as secondary offerings. Marley Spoon also labels recipes with dietary attributes including calorie-conscious, low-carb, and quick prep, allowing subscribers to filter their personalized menu accordingly. For households that eat everything and want high-quality, elevated home cooking across all recipe categories, Marley Spoon's menu is comprehensive and consistently interesting.

Purple Carrot is entirely plant-based. Every recipe in the weekly rotation is 100 percent vegan, and the catalog is designed from the ground up to reflect plant-based culinary expertise rather than adapted omnivore recipes. The service also labels within its vegan menu for gluten-free and soy-free options, providing useful guidance for subscribers with additional restrictions. For households committed to veganism or plant-based eating as a lifestyle, the alignment between Purple Carrot's catalog and their dietary needs is seamless, there is no filtering required, no disappointment when the meat-based options look better than the vegetarian alternatives, and no compromise on recipe quality or creativity relative to the omnivore-focused services.

Flexibility and Cancellation

Marley Spoon uses a straightforward weekly subscription format consistent with the HelloFresh portfolio standards. Account management is clean and feature-complete: you can adjust your weekly recipe count and serving size, skip individual deliveries, pause your subscription temporarily, or cancel entirely through the app or website. The skip cutoff is typically three to five days before your scheduled delivery date. There are no cancellation fees. New subscribers should note that Marley Spoon's promotional first-box pricing is tied to a continuing subscription, so setting a calendar reminder to cancel if you do not intend to continue is worthwhile after taking advantage of a first-box discount.

Purple Carrot's account management mirrors Marley Spoon's in most respects, reflecting the shared HelloFresh ownership infrastructure. You can modify serving size, recipe count, dietary preferences, delivery frequency, and payment information through the account portal. Skipping weeks is straightforward and can be done with a few days' notice. Cancellation is fee-free and fully self-service online. For subscribers who batch cook or prefer biweekly delivery to reduce the weekly management overhead, the delivery frequency setting is particularly useful, many Purple Carrot subscribers find that a delivery every two weeks aligns better with their actual consumption rate than a weekly cadence.

Bottom Line: Which Service Should You Choose

Marley Spoon and Purple Carrot both occupy the premium tier of the meal kit market, and the choice between them ultimately comes down to whether you want to incorporate animal proteins into your weekly meals or not. For households that eat meat and fish and want an elevated, Martha Stewart-quality cooking experience at home, Marley Spoon is one of the best premium meal kits available. The recipe quality and ingredient sourcing are consistently strong, the per-serving cost is lower than Purple Carrot for comparable meal counts, and the broad menu rotation covers a wide range of cuisines and cooking styles without restricting your choices to a single dietary lane.

For households that are fully committed to veganism or are actively working toward reducing animal product consumption, Purple Carrot provides a weekly cooking experience that no other meal kit service matches on the specific dimension of high-quality plant-based cuisine. The menu creativity, specialty ingredient sourcing, and recipe skill-building are all calibrated for subscribers who take plant-based cooking seriously rather than treating it as a secondary option. At 11.99 per serving, the price is justified by what the service delivers within its category. If eliminating the frustration of filtered menus and mediocre vegetarian options from a mixed-diet service is worth a 25 to 30 percent price premium over Marley Spoon, Purple Carrot is unequivocally worth it.

Key Differences: Marley Spoon vs Purple Carrot Summary

Marley Spoon and Purple Carrot share a parent company in HelloFresh, which means delivery reliability, account management, and operational quality are comparable between the two services. The meaningful differences are in menu philosophy and target customer. Marley Spoon serves omnivore households that want elevated, Martha Stewart-quality home cooking across a broad range of cuisines including meat, seafood, and vegetarian. The weekly menu rotation of 30 to 40 recipes provides enough variety to remain engaging over many months of subscribing, and the ingredient quality justifies the premium over budget competitors like EveryPlate or Dinnerly.

Purple Carrot serves plant-based households that want premium weekly recipes designed specifically for vegan cooking rather than adapted from omnivore formats. The per-serving cost is approximately 33 percent higher than Marley Spoon, which is the price of specialization, the specialty plant-based ingredients and cuisine-specific recipe development that Purple Carrot provides cost more than the conventional proteins and produce at the center of Marley Spoon's menu. For households that are fully plant-based, that premium buys a qualitatively better weekly cooking experience than any general meal kit's vegetarian options can match. Choosing between the two services is straightforward once you know your dietary household type.

Where to Order in Your City

Both services deliver to most major US cities. Find local availability and the latest deals in your area:

• Meal delivery in New York City
• Meal delivery in Los Angeles
• Meal delivery in Chicago
• Meal delivery in Houston
• Meal delivery in Phoenix
• Meal delivery in Philadelphia
• Meal delivery in San Antonio
• Meal delivery in Dallas