Reveal the 4 Wild Alaskan Seafood Alternatives You Absolutely Shouldn’t Ignore

Last Updated : February 23, 2024

Wild Alaskan Seafood Life Alternatives

Subscribing to a seafood meal delivery service for the first time? It opens up a world of convenience, variety, and quality, especially if you’re a seafood lover.

Online seafood delivery services tend to offer more value than local fish markets when it comes to trying out new seafood recipes. You get to buy local and global varieties of seafood that are pre-cleaned and preportioned, saving you time and energy during the cooking process.

Wild Alaskan Seafood Delivery is one of the top competitors for buying eco-friendly and high-quality seafood online. It offers an impressive range of seafood, plus a personalized subscription plan that you can opt for if you want the best-selling items on its menu.

And just like Wild Alaskan Seafood, there are plenty of convenient services that sell and ship premium seafood right to your doorstep. They offer seafood in different cuts, portion sizes, catches, and prices.

It’s best to keep your options open if you don’t like everything Wild Alaskan Seafood has to offer.

Wild Alaskan Seafood – An Overview

Wild Alaskan Seafood is one of the best sustainable seafood options for people who want wild-caught seafood without any antibiotics, GMOs, or additives. They deliver their fish straight from Alaska and the Pacific Northwest.

With several different seafood box plans, you can choose from a wide variety of portion sizes and cuts, plus add-ons that spruce up your personalized seafood box.

They let you pick your ideal seafood options, focusing on quality and ease of preparation. If you want something specific like salmon, you can select their Wild Salmon Box. If you want wild white fish, they even have a Wild White Fish Box for you.

On top of that, if you want a combination of both, the Wild Combo Box featuring 12 or 24 single-serve portions of salmon and wild white fish is an option to select as well.

Based on the availability, their website features different types of wild-caught seafood such as Coho Salmon, Pacific Cod, Pacific Halibut, Sockeye Salmon, Pacific Rockfish, and Wild Alaska Pollock.

The most impressive thing about subscribing to Wild Alaskan Seafood is that they offer a money-back guarantee, which means that if you don’t like their seafood plans, you get a full refund, no questions asked!

Wild Alaskan Seafood Cost

The pricing plans of Wild Alaskan Seafood are easy to understand.

If you plan on investing in the 12-pack seafood box, the price starts from $145 per box. And for the 24-pack seafood box, the price is $264 per shipment. The average cost per serving starts from $11 on larger orders. Shipping is absolutely free.

One minor drawback to this is that the Wild Alaskan Seafood Company only delivers once per month. The good news is that there is a 100% money-back guarantee. Plus, you get benefits like skipping or canceling the meal box at any time. You can even change the schedule of your deliveries easily before the deadline.

The Exclusive Member Special add-ons start from $40 per box.

Wild Alaskan Seafood Pros and Cons


  • Sustainably farmed seafood and GMO-free.
  • No antibiotics, fillers, or additives.
  • Plans start from $11 per portion.
  • Fish is high in B vitamins and potassium.
  • Flash-frozen meat to preserve freshness and flavor.
  • Free shipping across the USA.
  • Add-ons are exclusive for members (prawns, crabs, salmon, scallops).
  • Skipping and cancellation are easy to do.


  • The minimum order is 12 portions.
  • One-time order is expensive.
  • Delivers only once a month.

Wild Alaskan Seafood Recipes and Meal Variety

Diets like Mediterranean, keto, paleo, and pescatarian encourage higher consumption of fish. The type of sustainable seafood Wild Alaskan Seafood Company provides can give you a good boost of essential nutrients like B vitamins, omega-3, selenium, and potassium.

Plus, they deliver high-quality and antibiotic- and GMO-free seafood, which is ideal for anyone looking to avoid processed foods in their diet. It’s supportive of clean eating habits that reduce inflammation, boost immunity, and improve overall health and well-being.

Before revealing their seafood box options, even though Wild Alaskan Seafood Company does not serve meal recipes, they do give you recipe ideas and inspirations on their website. On top of the recipe details, they provide additional helpful information like prep time, cooking time, nutrient value, and the serving size of each recipe.

Moving on, variety-wise, they offer three seafood boxes:

  • Wild Combo Box: This features different types of wild-caught salmon and white fish. The seafood is vacuum-sealed and requires minimal prep to cook up as a meal. Options like Coho and Sockeye Salmon, Pacific Cod, Halibut, and Rockfish are included.
  • Wild Salmon Box: This features fresh and authentic cuts of wild salmon that you can quickly prep and cook by selecting the recipes on their website. The fish is packed in vacuum-sealed packs with proper storage and thawing instructions printed on the label. You’ll receive a box of Coho and Sockeye Salmon.
  • Wild White Fish Box: This features high-quality wild white fish in a variety of cuts. Again, the fish is packed in vacuum-sealed bags that you can store easily in the freezer after unpacking. You’ll receive Pacific Cod, Halibut, and Rockfish.

Similarly, portion-wise, they offer two box options – 12-pack and 24-pack box size.

The former is good for people subscribing for themselves or for two people. The fish measures up to 6 ounces per serving. The latter offers a generous serving size, which includes 24 pieces of 6-ounce fish, great for large groups and families.

The Exclusive Member Specials offer a wide selection of weekly rotating add-ons like prawns, crab, scallops, steaks, and more. Just like salmon and white fish, these add-ons are 100% sustainably sourced with no antibiotics, colorants, dyes, GMOs, or additives.

Wild Alaskan Seafood Alternative #1 – Sitka Salmon Shares

Wild Alaskan seafood is quite popular because of one too many reasons, including abundant diversity, high nutritional profile, sustainable fishing, and pristine environment. Seafood lovers are magnetically pulled toward the clean, untouched waters of Alaska, which consist of different kinds of seafood species that are harvested responsibly.

And one company that delivers this type of premium-quality, sustainable seafood directly from fishermen straight to your doorstep is Sitka Salmon Shares. So, you can get your fatty acids, lean proteins, and vitamins just like that!

It’s a subscription-based meal delivery service that gives you the option of paying monthly or full upfront. Also, it works in favor of Sitka Salmon Shares to know that these guys here really care about ecological impact. Sustainable methods and practices are followed. They also truly care about the fishing communities and fisheries of Alaska.

In short, it’s a Community Supported Fishery (CSF) seafood delivery service. As a consumer, you buy the “shares” of the upcoming fishing season’s seafood harvest. How many shares are purchased will decide how much the fisherman will catch.

As for your share, your wild Alaskan catch is sent to you on a monthly basis throughout the fishing season – from April to December. The weight and species of the fish vary depending on the meal plan you choose.

The fisheries in Alaska are responsibly managed, as is established already. The fishing methods used for catching Sitka’s fish prioritize the maximization of ecological and social well-being. The seafood delivered to you is individually caught, and this wild-caught fish is blast-frozen immediately to lock in the freshness. That’s how and why Sitka Salmon Shares seafood tastes so fresh, clean, delicious, and briny!

Sitka Salmon Shares Cost

There are 3 meal plan options and you have to select any one that fits the bill for you:

  • Premium Seafood Box: $159 per box
  • Seafood Box: $139 per box
  • Salmon Box: $129 per box

As for shipping, it’s free of charge, which means the delivery charges are included in the meal plans.

You can also choose Sitka Salmon one-time boxes, for example, the Sitka Seafood Intro Box, which is a 3-pound box that contains two different types of species for $99 only.

Sitka Salmon Shares Pros and Cons


  • Delivers the highest-quality wild Alaska salmon.
  • Includes sockeye, silver, coho, and king salmon options.
  • Very transparent about their sustainable fishing practices.
  • The recipes menu is very diverse for newbies and seasoned cooks.
  • Accommodates shellfish-related food allergies.


  • Salmon might be a little too expensive.
  • Monthly deliveries, thus you need to plan meals ahead of time.

Sitka Salmon Shares Recipes and Meal Variety

On Sitka Salmon Shares, there’s no lack of meal variety. One look at the Culinary section, equipped with wide-ranging menu filters, and you’ll go bonkers if you can’t get enough of seafood. They’re all unforgettably delicious salmon, shrimp, etc. recipes with high-quality, fresh ingredients (responsibly sourced) that nourish your senses and body.

Start your busy day with their Wild Alaskan Salmon Benedict – poached eggs over grilled wild Alaskan sockeye salmon with roasted potatoes in hollandaise sauce. The dish is gluten-free and loaded with tons of lean proteins and omega-3 fatty acids.

An irresistible lunch or dinner meal would be Sitka Salmon Shares’ signature Wild Alaskan Salmon Tacos. Corn tortillas with a filling of pan-seared wild king salmon plus fresh cabbage, lime crema, and pico de gallo. The portion of wild salmon, as well as vegetables, is quite generous. It’s a simple recipe but extremely flavorful nonetheless.

The Wild Alaskan Salmon Cakes of Sitka Salmon Shares is another customer favorite. These are pan-friend salmon cakes that consist of fresh wild coho salmon, breadcrumbs, and herbs, with roasted asparagus and caper dill sauce. Once again, the dish is gluten-free and also mildly spiced. Furthermore, it’s just the perfect option for someone with a shellfish allergy.

Speaking of which, does Sitka Salmon Shares offer allergy-friendly seafood meals? Their Premium Seafood Box contains meals without shellfish. You get other options like king salmon, albacore tuna, sablefish, halibut, Pacific cod, coho salmon, and Bristol Bay sockeye salmon, so no more having to deal with annoying shellfish allergies!

Wild Alaskan Seafood Alternative #2 – Tanner’s Alaskan Seafood

Another sustainable and healthy seafood delivery company, Tanner’s Alaskan Seafood offers an impressive variety of seafood options including items like gourmet seafood batters, exotic meats, quick and healthy dinners, gift baskets, and canned foods.

It’s also a subscription-based company that lets you pick different quantities of fish starting from $99.95. You can opt for a monthly subscription plan or place multiple orders at once.

Their menu consists of an interesting blend of options where you get to shop for different portions of fish like the Alaskan salmon, halibut, crabs, scallops, cod, rockfish, shrimp, calamari, octopus, and other exotic fish.

They also offer a catalog of recipes divided into varying categories, such as batters and spices, halibut recipes, cod recipes, calamari recipes, shrimp recipes, salmon, recipes, and so on.

Comparable to other seafood delivery services, especially Wild Alaskan Seafood Company, Tanner’s offers free overnight shipping on orders that pack more than 8 pounds of fish. The downside to this though is that you have to pay a shipping fee under 8 pounds.

Tanner’s Alaskan Seafood Cost

Different seafood products on their website come with varying prices. One pound of Alaskan Salmon, for example, costs $20. Plus, you’ll have to pay shipping on orders below 8 pounds – the shipping charges are higher than usual, amounting to $35–$50 per order.

You can order combos that cost more than $100, which include more than 2 pounds of any two different types of flash-frozen fish. All the items have customer reviews with colorful pictures of the fish or dish you’re planning to add to your cart.

Tanner’s Alaskan Seafood Pros and Cons


  • Fresh and superior-quality seafood.
  • Sustainably sourced with no GMOs, preservatives, or fillers.
  • The seafood is flash-frozen and delivered.
  • Overnight delivery for orders over $100.
  • A wide variety of seafood recipes are included.
  • Subscription boxes for combo products.
  • Responsive customer service.


  • The cost is higher than usual.
  • Shipping for small orders is longer.

Tanner’s Alaskan Seafood Recipes and Meal Variety

Tanner’s Alaskan Seafood Company offers wild-caught, sustainable, and fresh Alaskan seafood. Their menu boasts a diverse variety of seafood options from salmon, halibut, rockfish, and cod to scallops, shrimp, crab, and much more.

All their seafood products are processed without GMOs, additives, preservatives, and fillers. Delivered in a sustainable way, the meat quality is consistent and well-portioned.

Whether you’re on a complete pescatarian diet or any other specialized diet plan that encourages a high consumption of fish, Tanner’s Alaskan Seafood will suit you. You won’t run out of recipe ideas, especially since they offer an entire seafood recipes menu for you to browse through.

They practice fresh fish processing, which prioritizes sustainable sourcing of seafood. The fish is caught based on your order specifications, and then the fish is flash-frozen and packed in vacuum-sealed bags. This preserves the freshness and flavor to a greater degree.

Together with their subscription boxes, they offer different types of seafood such as the following:

  • Salmon
  • Smoked salmon
  • Halibut
  • Crab
  • Shrimp
  • Pollock
  • Cod
  • Clams
  • Mussels
  • Caviar
  • Roe
  • Lobster
  • Octopus
  • Sushi

Wild Alaskan Seafood Alternative #3 – Wild for Salmon

With Wild for Salmon meal delivery service, you get to experience the deliciousness and convenience of wild Alaskan seafood. What began as just an adventure in 2002 turned into a business opportunity for Steve and Jenn Kurian, founders of Wild for Salmon.

They continuously understand the uniqueness of a product like Alaskan wild-caught salmon. And now, the company serves not just individuals but also local farm markets, health food stores, restaurants, and buying clubs.

The meal plan options allow you to customize your dishes based on your dietary preferences and restrictions. This subscription-based seafood meal delivery service offers regular deliveries of sustainably caught, fresh salmon, along with other seafood. The company certainly prioritizes seafood that’s wild-caught since it’s a more natural choice than farmed fish.

Wild-caught seafood has a superior flavor and texture and higher nutritional content. The higher nutritional value here also means your fish doesn’t contain artificial additives, antibiotics, etc.

It’s a fishermen-owned business that delivers to your doorstep fresh and frozen wild Alaskan sockeye salmon at a very budget-friendly price.

Wild for Salmon Cost

The price is based on which meal plan you pick. For instance, the most basic one starts at $79 per week. You get 2 meals weekly, which are equipped with 6–8 ounces of fresh, wild-caught salmon paired with starch and vegetables.

The premium meal plan starts at $119 per week with 8–12 ounces of wild-caught salmon and very satisfying portions of sides.

The shipping fee is $9.5 per order.

Wild for Salmon is indeed a slightly more expensive meal delivery service for seafood. The premium quality of the seafood is what increases the cost, so it’s totally worth it. Plus, this is high-quality, fresh fish combined with the convenience of meal preparation.

Wild for Salmon Pros and Cons


  • Fresh, premium-quality seafood with high nutritional value.
  • Ingredients are preportioned and recipes are easy to follow.
  • Over 50 seafood recipes are on the menu.
  • Shop by collection – Alaskan Salmon, Alaskan Whitefish, and more.
  • A wide range of menu categories.


  • Limited customization of meals
  • Higher prices per serving

Wild for Salmon Recipes and Meal Variety

Healthy meals and delicious meals, both are a part of the Wild for Salmon variety of recipes. The menu gives you more than 50 options to choose from – all fresh, wild-caught salmon. The diverse range of flavors includes Latin American, Asian, and Mediterranean cuisines.

All recipes are balanced and highly nutritious, and each meal features salmon with whole grains and vegetables. There are also omega-3 fatty acids and lean proteins packed in salmon and other additional nutrients coming from ingredients like beans, leafy greens, and quinoa.

You can choose between family and individual meals on Wild for Salmon. The former is the best for generous portions (3 or 4 servings), and the latter takes the form of single-serve meals (1 or 2 servings).

For single-serve or individual meals, you can select the recipes you want per week. Your options can be the following:

  • Teriyaki Salmon Bowls
  • Salmon Cakes with Mango Salsa
  • Salmon Burgers with Sweet Potato Fries

As for the family-sized meals, you can choose between 3 and 4 recipes every week. There’s a good amount of meal variety in this case too that seems to work perfectly for the entire household. These are all home-cooked types of meals that are both simple to put together and delicious to consume.

Wild Alaskan Seafood Alternative #4 – Sizzlefish Seafood

Sizzlefish is another very convenient seafood delivery company that offers a wide spectrum of seafood options, such as 15 different types of fish, 11 types of shellfish, and beef.

It’s also a subscription-based ocean-friendly seafood delivery company. You can choose the ideal subscription box. Also, if you want Sizzlefish to pick what’s best, that’s also possible.

Their box selection includes different portion sizes of seafood, a la carte options, and personalized combo options. The seafood is flash-frozen and packaged.

If you’re a seafood lover, you will find plenty of interesting options to pick from Sizzlefish. The subscription plans are easy to understand and access. And even if you don’t want to commit to their subscription plans on your first order, you can order a smaller quantity of seafood without any hassle.

The majority of the seafood is wildly caught, but they do serve some farmed fish like rainbow trout, catfish, and Atlantic salmon. The seafood is sold without any antibiotics, preservatives, fillers, or additives.

The seafood is packed in sustainable and eco-friendly containers. The food is vacuum-sealed and stored using dry ice, which means that the dry ice has to melt completely before you can transfer the packages to your freezer. This might take some time depending on the delivery location, but it’s more convenient since you don’t have to deal with gel ice packs during unpacking.

Sizzlefish Seafood Delivery Cost

Browsing the Sizzlefish menu is fast and fun. By selecting the “price low to high” option, you’ll see how flexible their menu is price-wise. The cost starts from $10 for a 6-ounce portion to $250 for 3 pounds of wild Alaskan king crab legs.

There is a wide variety of seafood and beef options in between the $10 and $250 price range.

Shipping is automatically free on orders above $100. And it’s better to keep your order to a minimum of $100 because the shipping cost under $100 is $20. You might as well order more fish than pay an empty price of $20 for shipping. It’s the smarter thing to do.

Sizzlefish Seafood Pros and Cons


  • Great selection of fish, shellfish, and beef.
  • Eco-friendly, high-quality seafood.
  • It’s flash-frozen to prolong freshness and shelf life.
  • Packaging is minimal and durable.
  • The seafood is stored with dry ice to save space.
  • Smooth and consistent delivery.
  • Multiple subscription boxes are included.


  • The menu may be confusing for newcomers.
  • You must contact customer support for cancellation.
  • Some of the items are expensive.

Sizzlefish Seafood Recipes and Meal Variety

Their menu lets you choose the featured seafood and meat options. But you can also filter the vast variety of options according to price, alphabet, and time.

The Fish options include salmon, sea bass, halibut, cod, haddock, catfish, sablefish, rockfish, tuna, red snapper, walleye, and lots more. Shellfish includes shrimp, crab, scallops, crab cakes, lobster, calamari, clams, mussels, and more. Premium beef items like ribeye, filet mignon, New York strip, and ground beef are also a part of their menu.

Together with their gourmet selection of different types of seafood and beef, they also offer pre-prepped and pre-marinated fish recipes like Maryland Crab Cake Bites and Smoked Roasted Wild Copper River Sockeye Salmon.

Their menu also includes different subscription plans, such as Prime Subscription, Prime Plus Box, and the Wild Seafood Favorites Box.

Out of the three, the third option is curated for you, which means Sizzlefish selects the best seafood options for you. The box includes different varieties of fish caught fresh and delivered once a month.

The meal selection process is simple and quick. Once you select the food you want, the seafood is shipped frozen to preserve the flavor and freshness.

As opposed to delivering unfrozen fish, companies always run the risk of delivering stale or spoiled fish by the time the package arrives at your doorstep. Freezing the seafood right after sourcing is the best way to keep food fresh and delicious.

This enables you to keep the fish in the freezer for months until cooking. Sizzlefish uses minimal packaging that lets you stack all kinds of seafood easily. All the products are labeled and come with the necessary instructions for storage, cooking, and freshness date.

Why Choose These Alternatives Over Wild Alaskan Seafood?

For a greater variety of seafood items: Tanner’s seafood menu is the most versatile, ideal for seafood lovers and picky eaters. They even offer easy and delicious seafood recipes that you can refer to after placing an order. The seafood and recipes are divided according to seafood type, offering better flexibility in the selection process.

Sizzlefish also competes well against Wild Alaskan Seafood with its flexible subscription plans and a wide variety of seafood options. Plus, they offer premium beef choices that are hormone-free and non-GMO. Everything is flash-frozen and tastes fresh after cooking, so you can stock up on interesting portions of fish for weeks at a time.

For allergy-friendly seafood meals: If you choose Sitka Salmon Shares, you can eliminate a common allergy-triggering food – shellfish. The Sitka Salmon Shares menu features plenty of filters to accommodate dietary concerns among many others. Moreover, their Premium Seafood Box meal plan includes meals without shellfish.

For family-friendly seafood meals: Wild for Salmon offers larger serving sizes, along with portion sizes for individuals and couples of course. So, if you want your weekly orders to accommodate seafood-based meals for the whole family, the 3-serving and 4-serving size options on Wild for Salmon are the best.

Buying Seafood Online – Benefits of Subscribing to a Seafood Meal Delivery Service

Ordering seafood online is a convenient process. It is the perfect option for someone looking for a wider variety of seafood to explore. The seafood delivery companies mentioned in this article offer tons of exceptional benefits, both price-wise and variety-wise, without compromising on quality.

This is what you get when you decide to subscribe to a seafood delivery company for the first time.

1. At-Home Convenience

You can effortlessly order your first seafood meal box from the comfort of your own home. It saves time and energy as you skip visiting the local fish market or supermarket. Some grocery stores do not match up to the variety of seafood options available online.

Avoiding the hassle of cleaning, prepping, and filleting seafood is also an important benefit. The seafood that is delivered to you is pre-cleaned, preportioned, and ready to cook in minutes.

2. Flexible Pricing

As opposed to settling for the fixed prices of seafood, which are mostly expensive, in a local fish market or grocery store, online seafood delivery companies give you plenty of options to experiment with.

You gain access to a wider variety of seafood, in varying portions, compared to the limited and restricted prices found offline.

You can explore different types of fish and shellfish that are sustainably sourced. You’ll also be presented with some premium exotic species that may not be available in a local supermarket.

One of the top reasons for opting for online shopping is that you get access to different discounts and offers. Seafood delivery services offer competitive pricing and exclusive deals, especially for first-timers.

3. Quality Assurance

The seafood packed and delivered by seafood delivery companies is sustainable and always fresh. Based on the size of the order, the fish is wildly caught and flash-frozen to preserve freshness and flavor.

Some companies implement strict quality control measures for sourcing and handling seafood. Plus, they make use of convenient packaging like dry ice, vacuum-sealed bags, insulated containers, etc. that makes unpacking less of a hassle for you.

4. Prompt Deliveries

Another benefit to buying seafood online is that you get to decide the schedule of deliveries. You also get tracking information with real-time updates regarding the delivery of your order. Depending on where you live, you can choose the right time of day for deliveries. Plus, skipping a week, pausing a subscription, or canceling an order is also possible.


Wild Alaskan Seafood is a fine choice for fresh and high-quality seafood deliveries. They offer hand-selected and sustainable seafood but at a relatively higher price. This article recommends a variety of other reputable services that pack and deliver fresh seafood.

In fact, some services also recommend delicious seafood recipes that you can refer to after receiving your first order. The seafood remains at peak freshness during and after transit.

And you get to pick from different a la carte options, subscription boxes, or personalized combos. For a highly customizable and seamless experience, the alternatives to Wild Alaskan Seafood are some of the best in the business.