Justin's Super Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups
6.2out of 10
MealFan score Ranked #69 of 72 nut butters we scoredSee the full ranking →
Justin's

Super Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

MealFan pickBest lower sugar dark chocolate PB cup
Community rating Tried this product? Your rating helps the next shopper. Be the first to rate it Rate or review this productShare this product
protein
2g
Best for
Clean label
Where to buy → · price varies by store
Share this review X Facebook Pinterest
Independent reviewBased on the product label. No sponsored placement.
Market position

How it compares

Open the full comparison
#69of 72 nut butters scored
Category average7.71.5 below average
achvaTahiniCompare head to head 9.7out of 10 Sesame KingTahini Paste (Roasted)Compare head to head 9.7out of 10 Wegmans OrganicTahiniCompare head to head 9.7out of 10
!

The catch

Each small 20g cup packs 5g of saturated fat, a quarter of the daily value, so the fat and sugar add up fast if you eat more than one. (source)

The honest take

These are organic peanut butter cups made with 80% cacao dark chocolate, and the label is cleaner than most candy in the aisle. One cup runs 130 calories with just 5g of total sugar, all of it added, from a short list of organic ingredients with no stevia and no sugar alcohols. The catch is that each small 20g cup still carries 5g of saturated fat, a quarter of the daily value, and almost nobody stops at one. Treat them as a real treat rather than a health food and they hold up well.
Explore the brand

The Justin's product guide

18 products reviewed
Justin's Justin’s Almond butterJustin’s Almond butterBest low sugar no stir almond butter7.8Justin's Almond ButterAlmond ButterBest no added sugar almond butter for clean snacking7.8Justin's Classic Peanut Butter SpreadClassic Peanut Butter SpreadBest no stir natural peanut butter7.3Justin's PEANUT BUTTER SPREADPEANUT BUTTER SPREADBest no stir low sugar peanut butter7.3Justin's Peanut ButterPeanut ButterBest no stir low sugar peanut butter7.3

Nutrition per serving

1 cup (20g)

130Calories
2gProtein
8gCarbs
10gFat
1gFiber
5gSugar
75mgSodium
USDA OrganicNon GMO Project VerifiedGluten freeVeganNo sugar alcohols

Who it's for

✓ Buy it if

Someone who wants a genuine dark chocolate peanut butter cup with organic ingredients and only 5g of added sugar per piece.

✕ Skip it if

You watch saturated fat closely or you know one cup always turns into three.

✉ Get Justin's deals first

Exclusive discounts and drops. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Rate this product
Tap a star, no signup. Real buyer ratings help other shoppers choose.
Your experience

Write a review of Super Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups

No account needed. A specific, honest sentence is more useful than a long review.

September draw · entries close Sep 30
Add your email for a chance to win a $100 Amazon.com Gift Card.
A one star review counts exactly like a five.
Review progress0 of 2 complete
0 of 30 characters
Never shown on the site.
By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy, including email marketing and tailored ads on partner platforms.
No purchase necessary. You can also enter free by emailing [email protected] with the subject Review Draw Entry and your full name. Open to legal residents of the 50 US and DC, 18 and over. Void where prohibited. Odds depend on how many entries come in. I pick a winner at random by October 7. Sponsor: Luxer Agency. Amazon.com is not a sponsor of this promotion. Rules

Reviews are moderated before they publish. I approve reviews for honesty, never for the rating. Reviews written during a gift card draw are labeled.

Research desk

Compare nut butters side by side

Real nut butters from our directory, on the numbers that matter. The green check marks the best in each column. Tap a heading to rank them, tick the boxes to put 2 to 4 head to head, or click any product to open its full review.

Product MealFan Score ↕Protein ↕Calories ↕Sugar ↕Sodium ↕
Justin'sSuper Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups this product6.2/102g1305g75mg
Magic SpoonPeanut Butter Grain-Free Cereal 8.1/1014g1700g210mg
MonoprixLe Wrap falafel tomate tahini épinard 7.4/106.4g2022.3g364mg
bear nakedPeanut Butter 6.5/107g26414g80mg
Seed + MillOrganic Tahini 7.5/106g2000g0mg
Once AgainOrganic Tahini With Lemon 8.3/106g210n/a10mg
MillOrganic Tahini 9/1021g7140g0mg
ByblosSesame Tahini 7.7/108g2100g40mg
SadafTahini 9.7/1025g6790g0mg
CadiaOrganic Tahini 7.5/105.4g922.3g69mg
Wegmans OrganicTahini 9.7/1020g7000g0mg
SophiaTahini 8.2/1021g6790g0mg
Villa JeradaTahini 8/105g1800g0mg
Tick 1 to 3 boxes above to put them side by side
See all nut butters in the directory →

Your turn

Tried Justin's Super Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups, or weighing it against the others above? Add your honest take. Real shoppers use these reviews to decide what to put in the cart, and it takes a few seconds.

★ Write a review

Where to buy

AmazonTargetWhole FoodsVitacost

Around . Prices move with promos and store, so check before you buy. Some links are affiliate links and never change our verdict.

Our sources

Justin's official product page: Super Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups · EWG Food Scores: Justin's Organic Super Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups · MyFoodData Nutrition Facts: Justin's Super Dark Chocolate Cups. Nutrition is read from the manufacturer label and named sources, never brand marketing.

More pantry staples

Maya Kaimal Butter Masala Simmer Sauce
Maya Kaimal
Butter Masala Simmer Sauce
1g protein
Fishwife Mussels W Pepper And Garlic
Fishwife
Mussels W Pepper And Garlic
13g protein
Fishwife Smoked rainbow trout
Fishwife
Smoked rainbow trout
15g protein
Fishwife Anchovies In Spanish Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Fishwife
Anchovies In Spanish Extra Virgin Olive Oil
4g protein

How we review: scored on the verified label and named sources, never brand marketing. We flag the real tradeoff on every product. Some links are affiliate links; it never changes a verdict. No brand pays to appear here.