The best nut butters, ranked

1. #1 Santa Cruz OrganicCreamy Dark Roasted Peanut ButterHonest label review 8.1out of 10
2. #2 Smucker'sPeanut butterHonest label review 8.0out of 10
3. #3 Crazy Richard'sNatural Peanut ButterHonest label review 8.0out of 10
4. #4 JiffyPeanut butterHonest label review 7.9out of 10
5. #5 Simply NatureCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.9out of 10
6. #6 Pic'sPeanut Butter CrunchyHonest label review 7.9out of 10
7. #7 Smucker'sNatural Creamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.8out of 10
8. #8 Smucker'sNatural Peanut Butter CreamyHonest label review 7.8out of 10
9. #9 FreshonaPeanut Butter creamyHonest label review 7.8out of 10
10. #10 NuttZoOrganic 7 Nut & Seed Butter Power Fuel CrunchyHonest label review 7.7out of 10
11. #11 Reese'sCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.6out of 10
12. #12 JifExtra Crunchy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.5out of 10
13. #13 Peter PanPeanut ButterHonest label review 7.4out of 10
14. #14 JifCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
15. #15 SkippyCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
16. #16 Kirkland SignatureMixed Nut Butter with SeedsHonest label review 7.3out of 10
17. #17 Justin'sPeanut Butter SpreadBest no stir low sugar peanut butter 7.3out of 10
18. #18 SkippyNatural Creamy Peanut Butter SpreadHonest label review 7.3out of 10
19. #19 SkippyPeanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
20. #20 JifPeanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
21. #21 SkippyExtra Crunchy Super Chunk Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
22. #22 Justin'sClassic Peanut Butter SpreadBest no stir natural peanut butter 7.3out of 10
23. #23 Kirkland SignatureOrganic Creamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.2out of 10
24. #24 PB2Original Powdered Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.1out of 10
25. #25 PB2Powdered Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.1out of 10
26. #26 KINDAlmond Butter ClustersBest higher protein granola with a sugar catch 7.0out of 10
27. #27 JifPeanut Butter SpreadHonest label review 6.8out of 10
28. #28 Justin'sVanilla Almond ButterBest sweet vanilla nut butter treat 6.8out of 10
29. #29 Justin'sMaple Almond Butter JarsBest low added sugar sweet almond butter 6.8out of 10
30. #30 Bear NakedPeanut ButterHonest label review 6.5out of 10
31. #31 QuinnMini peanut butter nuggetHonest label review 6.4out of 10
32. #32 Justin'sSuper Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter CupsBest lower sugar dark chocolate PB cup 6.2out of 10
33. #33 Justin'sSuper Dark Chocolate Espresso Almond Butter CupsBest organic dark chocolate almond butter cup 6.2out of 10

How we score: the MealFan Score rewards protein and fiber and penalizes added sugar and sodium, read from the verified label. It is a starting point for comparison, not medical advice. Prices and formulas change, so check the pack before you buy.