🔥 50% off your first week of CookUnity + 10% off your next 3 boxes
Products › Pantry staple › Best Nut butters
🏆 MealFan Ranking

The best nut butters, ranked

Every nut butters in our directory, scored on the label that matters and ranked by MealFan Score. Higher protein and fiber lift the score, added sugar and sodium pull it down. No brand pays to appear here.

  1. #1 achva Tahini achvaTahiniHonest label review 9.7out of 10
  2. #2 Sesame King Tahini Paste (Roasted) Sesame KingTahini Paste (Roasted)Honest label review 9.7out of 10
  3. #3 Wegmans Organic Tahini Wegmans OrganicTahiniHonest label review 9.7out of 10
  4. #4 Sadaf Tahini SadafTahiniHonest label review 9.7out of 10
  5. #5 Makedoniko Tahini MakedonikoTahiniHonest label review 9.6out of 10
  6. #6 Magic Spoon PROTEIN GRANOLA Peanut Butter Magic SpoonPROTEIN GRANOLA Peanut ButterBest low sugar high protein granola 9.4out of 10
  7. #7 Mill Organic Tahini MillOrganic TahiniHonest label review 9.0out of 10
  8. #9 Trader Joe's Organic Tahini Trader Joe'sOrganic TahiniHonest label review 8.3out of 10
  9. #10 Simple truth organic Tahini Simple truth organicTahiniHonest label review 8.3out of 10
  10. #11 Once Again Organic Tahini With Lemon Once AgainOrganic Tahini With LemonHonest label review 8.3out of 10
  11. #12 Wild Harvest Organic Tahini Wild HarvestOrganic TahiniHonest label review 8.2out of 10
  12. #13 Sophia Tahini SophiaTahiniHonest label review 8.2out of 10
  13. #14 Santa Cruz Organic Creamy Dark Roasted Peanut Butter Santa Cruz OrganicCreamy Dark Roasted Peanut ButterHonest label review 8.1out of 10
  14. #15 Magic Spoon Peanut Butter Grain-Free Cereal Magic SpoonPeanut Butter Grain-Free CerealBest low sugar high protein cereal swap 8.1out of 10
  15. #16 Smuckers Peanut butter SmuckersPeanut butterHonest label review 8.0out of 10
  16. #17 Crazy Richard's Natural Peanut Butter Crazy Richard'sNatural Peanut ButterHonest label review 8.0out of 10
  17. #18 Villa Jerada Tahini Villa JeradaTahiniHonest label review 8.0out of 10
  18. #19 Jiffy Peanut butter JiffyPeanut butterHonest label review 7.9out of 10
  19. #20 Simply Nature Creamy Peanut Butter Simply NatureCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.9out of 10
  20. #21 Pic's Peanut Butter Crunchy Pic'sPeanut Butter CrunchyHonest label review 7.9out of 10
  21. #23 Once Again Creamy Tahini Once AgainCreamy TahiniHonest label review 7.9out of 10
  22. #24 Smucker's Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Smucker'sNatural Creamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.8out of 10
  23. #25 Smucker's Natural Peanut Butter Creamy Smucker'sNatural Peanut Butter CreamyHonest label review 7.8out of 10
  24. #26 Freshona Peanut Butter creamy FreshonaPeanut Butter creamyHonest label review 7.8out of 10
  25. #27 NuttZo Organic 7 Nut & Seed Butter POWER FUEL Crunchy NuttZoOrganic 7 Nut & Seed Butter POWER FUEL CrunchyHonest label review 7.7out of 10
  26. #28 Artisana Organics Raw Tahini Sesame Seed Butter Artisana OrganicsRaw Tahini Sesame Seed ButterHonest label review 7.7out of 10
  27. #29 Byblos Sesame Tahini ByblosSesame TahiniHonest label review 7.7out of 10
  28. #30 Reese's Creamy Peanut Butter Reese'sCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.6out of 10
  29. #31 Jif Extra Crunchy Peanut Butter JifExtra Crunchy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.5out of 10
  30. #33 Zb Importing Inc. Tahini Sesame Paste Zb Importing Inc.Tahini Sesame PasteHonest label review 7.5out of 10
  31. #34 Fresh Thyme Organic tahini Fresh ThymeOrganic tahiniHonest label review 7.5out of 10
  32. #35 Cadia Organic Tahini CadiaOrganic TahiniHonest label review 7.5out of 10
  33. #36 Seed + Mill Organic Tahini Seed + MillOrganic TahiniHonest label review 7.5out of 10
  34. #37 Peter Pan Peanut Butter Peter PanPeanut ButterHonest label review 7.4out of 10
  35. #38 Monoprix Le Wrap falafel tomate tahini épinard MonoprixLe Wrap falafel tomate tahini épinardHonest label review 7.4out of 10
  36. #39 Jif Creamy Peanut Butter JifCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
  37. #40 Skippy Creamy Peanut Butter SkippyCreamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
  38. #41 Kirkland Mixed Nut Butter with Seeds KirklandMixed Nut Butter with SeedsHonest label review 7.3out of 10
  39. #42 Justin's PEANUT BUTTER SPREAD Justin'sPEANUT BUTTER SPREADBest no stir low sugar peanut butter 7.3out of 10
  40. #43 Skippy Natural Creamy Peanut Butter Spread SkippyNatural Creamy Peanut Butter SpreadHonest label review 7.3out of 10
  41. #44 Skippy Peanut Butter SkippyPeanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
  42. #45 Jif Peanut Butter JifPeanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
  43. #46 SKIPPY Extra Crunchy Super Chunk Peanut Butter SKIPPYExtra Crunchy Super Chunk Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.3out of 10
  44. #47 Justin's Classic Peanut Butter Spread Justin'sClassic Peanut Butter SpreadBest no stir natural peanut butter 7.3out of 10
  45. #48 Kirkland Organic Creamy Peanut Butter KirklandOrganic Creamy Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.2out of 10
  46. #49 Lily's Peanut Butter Flavor Baking Chips Lily'sPeanut Butter Flavor Baking ChipsBest no sugar added peanut butter baking chip 7.2out of 10
  47. #50 Roland Tahini RolandTahiniHonest label review 7.2out of 10
  48. #51 Soom tahini SoomtahiniHonest label review 7.2out of 10
  49. #52 PB2 Original Powdered Peanut Butter PB2Original Powdered Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.1out of 10
  50. #53 PB2 Powdered Peanut Butter PB2Powdered Peanut ButterHonest label review 7.1out of 10
  51. #54 KIND Almond Butter Clusters KINDAlmond Butter ClustersBest higher protein granola with a sugar catch 7.0out of 10
  52. #55 KIND Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate KINDPeanut Butter Dark ChocolateBest whole nut peanut butter snack bar 7.0out of 10
  53. #56 Jif Peanut Butter Spread JifPeanut Butter SpreadHonest label review 6.8out of 10
  54. #57 Justin's Vanilla Almond Butter Justin'sVanilla Almond ButterBest sweet vanilla nut butter treat 6.8out of 10
  55. #58 Justin's Maple Almond Butter Jars Justin'sMaple Almond Butter JarsBest low added sugar sweet almond butter 6.8out of 10
  56. #60 MIGHTY SESAME CO. TAHINI MIGHTY SESAME CO.TAHINIHonest label review 6.7out of 10
  57. #61 KIND Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chewy Granola Clusters KINDDark Chocolate Peanut Butter Chewy Granola ClustersBest soft baked granola for a sweet tooth 6.7out of 10
  58. #62 GoMacro Organic Kids MacroBars Peanut Butter Cup GoMacroOrganic Kids MacroBars Peanut Butter CupHonest label review 6.6out of 10
  59. #63 Quinn Peanut Butter Filled Pretzel Nuggets QuinnPeanut Butter Filled Pretzel NuggetsHonest label review 6.6out of 10
  60. #64 bear naked Peanut Butter bear nakedPeanut ButterHonest label review 6.5out of 10
  61. #65 Quinn Mini peanut butter nugget QuinnMini peanut butter nuggetHonest label review 6.4out of 10
  62. #66 quinn PEANUT BUTTER & HONEY FILLED PRETZEL STICKS quinnPEANUT BUTTER & HONEY FILLED PRETZEL STICKSHonest label review 6.3out of 10
  63. #67 Quinn Peanut Butter And Honey Filled Pretzels QuinnPeanut Butter And Honey Filled PretzelsHonest label review 6.3out of 10
  64. #68 Quinn Maple Almond Butter Filled Pretzel Nuggets QuinnMaple Almond Butter Filled Pretzel NuggetsHonest label review 6.2out of 10
  65. #69 Justin's Super Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups Justin'sSuper Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter CupsBest lower sugar dark chocolate PB cup 6.2out of 10
  66. #70 Justin's Super Dark Chocolate Espresso Almond Butter Cups Justin'sSuper Dark Chocolate Espresso Almond Butter CupsBest organic dark chocolate almond butter cup 6.2out of 10

How we score: the MealFan Score rewards protein and fiber and penalizes added sugar and sodium, read from the verified label. It is a starting point for comparison, not medical advice. Prices and formulas change, so check the pack before you buy.

Browse all Pantry staples →
Browse
Top Cities
By Diet
Top Reviews
Mealfan · Independent meal delivery reviews since 2019 · Reviewed by Eric Sornoso
Write a review × Browse menu
Specialty Meal Delivery Guides Best Meal Delivery High Protein Diabetic GLP 1 Friendly
MFORD-wt

Trending · GLP-1 nutrition

Eating on a GLP-1? We test for that too.

Smaller appetite, same nutrition needs. We rank meal services and write guides around the protein-first, small-portion approach that works during titration.

Get the free GLP-1 meal plan →60-second quiz · matched to your budget and diet
High protein steak plate from a GLP-1 friendly meal serviceGLP-1 Meal Delivery58 guides · Start hereLight vegetable forward meal that is easy on a GLP-1 stomachFoods to AvoidGuideLean chicken and broccoli plate for protein on GLP-1Protein & MuscleGuide

Eating right

By medication

Next-gen & data

Browse all 58 GLP-1 guides →
What will it really cost?Real per-week math for every service: servings, shipping, first-box deals included.COST CALCULATOR →Find your kit in 60 secondsAnswer a few questions, get the services that actually fit how you eat.KIT FINDER →Every working code, one pageCurrent offers for all 45+ services, checked and dated, no expired coupon roulette.COUPONS →

This week’s menus

Live menus, refreshed weekly

Best for your need

46 ranked guides

Local guides

Meal delivery near you.

We test every major service in every state. Pick your city or state for local pricing, delivery coverage, and the picks that actually fit your zip code.

All 50 states